Best Toilet Seat –  Ultimate 2018 Buyer’s Guide and Reviews

Probably you don’t really think about it that much: that seat that is underneath you whenever nature calls, do you? Whatever that happens behind the curtain of your cloakroom definitely is something no one will want to talk about in public.

A toilet seat is a bathroom item that literally everyone has to have but there’s not a single person who gives it a second thought. It is obvious that you spend at least five minutes on the toilet (even more if it happens that you have a smartphone) a couple of times a day.

Therefore, if you use it that much, it has to be comfortable. A good toilet seat makes your bathroom elegant and comfortable. Health and safety is another reason as to why you should install the best toilet seat in any kind of amenity that a washroom is necessary. It is wise making an investment in a toilet model that is durable.

If you’re in the market for the best throne to sit, you should be very careful on the choice you make as this is a very important choice that shouldn’t be underestimated. Nevertheless, it’s not a walk in the park choosing the best toilet seat as there is a variety of them in the market.

However, we have simplified your work as we review the best toilet seats that the market has to currently offer.

Recommended Top 10 Best Toilet Seats

  1. Bath Royale Premium Round Toilet Seat
  2. Kohler K-4648-0 Stone Wood Toilet Seat
  3. Mayfair 148SLOWA 000 Slow – Close Molded Wood Commode Seat
  4. Toto SS114 O1 SoftClose Commode Seat
  5. Bemis 500EC146 Molded Wood Round Toilet Seat
  6. Mayfair 83SLOWA 000 NextStep Toilet Seat
  7. Brondell L60-RW LumaWarm Heated Nightlight Toilet Seat
  8. American Standard 5325.010.020 Champion Slow Close Commode Seat
  9. KOHLER K-4636-0 Cachet Quiet-Close Round Toilet Seat
  10. Mayfair 48SLOWA 000 Elongated Toilet Seat

Bath Royale Premium Round Toilet Seat

The Bath Royale toilet seat simply provides a royal experience. It is an elongated model that literally fits all the toilet brands. In fact, it matches almost any bathroom décor. It is made from polypropylene that makes it durable, sturdy, and fade resistant.

It has 4-foot bumpers that evenly distribute the weight of the user making it comfortable and very convenient. It has an I-Touch release function that makes cleaning easy while the soft technology that it’s made from prevents slams as well as accidents.

For the elderly, kids, and the physically challenged, it is ideal for use. It has a gloss finish which enables to appear new all the time as it resists scratches and damages.

Has a capacity of up to 400lbs hence appropriate for overweight individuals.


  • It’s durable
  • Has a high weight capacity
  • Comfortable design
  • Soft close technology
  • Fits almost all toilet brands
  • Easy to clean
  • 2-year warranty


  • Only for elongated toilets
  • Closes too slowly

Kohler K-4648-0 Stone Wood Toilet Seat

Kohler K-4648-0 toilet seat has a compression-molded wood which gives an exceptional look and feels that you can’t ignore. It is very durable as it doesn’t break or crack when under pressure.

It has plastic hinges that made to precision specifically for quality as well as ensure a slow closing and opening. Also, they prevent any crashing of the seat into the bowl.

It comes in many color options that you can choose from hence it doesn’t provide only a single option for color-maybe one that you don’t like.

It is very versatile as it’s highly compatible with toilet designs. It is also very comfortable thanks to the rounded edges.

The Kohler is as well durable and it’s easily installed and maintained. It is a seat with great quality but a relatively low price tag.


  • Very comfortable
  • Low price
  • Heavy and durable
  • Fit for small bathrooms


  • Weak hinges
  • Uncomfortable for tall people

Mayfair 148SLOWA 000 Slow – Close Molded Wood Commode Seat

The Mayfair molded wood commode toilet seat is the one you’ve been looking for. It never loosens after you install it. It has an STA-TITE system which allows an easy fix yourself and will thereafter remain sturdy.

The seat is made of durable wood hence will last for a long a period of time. More, the wood has a gloss finish which will match each type of décor. Even better, it resists chipping and scratching meaning you’re assured of it serving you and won’t lose its appeal for long.

It is very easy to clean this seat as it has a hinge system that makes it easy to remove and clean. It also makes renovation faster as you can easily remove it.

It has a whisper-close feature which eliminates trapping and slamming of fingers. Its construction is also environmental friendly hence makes its use safe.


  • It’s easy to clean
  • Good price
  • Easy to install
  • No fingers slamming and trapping
  • It’s sturdy and comfortable
  • Durable


  • Installation instructions are poor
  • A shorter warranty of a month

Toto SS114 O1 SoftClose Commode Seat

Toto SS11401 SoftClose commode seat will definitely make you forget everything about toilet slamming. It has a soft close design making it close slowly and smoothly.

Therefore, the cracking toilets that result from high-impact bang are eliminated. This seat will have you worry less of your kids being pinched closing it.

It is built from polypropylene material hence it is durable and sturdy to serve for a longer period. The material is also chemical as well as stain resistant making maintenance of the white color easy.

It has an ergonomic design that is comfortable to use. It also features a thermal insulator which prevents the user from feeling any cold while using it.

It is very easy to install this seat and comes with installation hardware hence no additional cash to be spent on its installation.


  • Durable
  • Matches all decors
  • Closes very smoothly and silently
  • Easy to install
  • Affordable price
  • Ergonomic design
  • Comfortably molded bumpers


  • High maintenance required

Bemis 500EC146 Molded Wood Round Toilet Seat

The real value for your money is the Bemis 500EC146 Molded Wood Round Toilet Seat. This is versatile toilet seat that features a warm and comfortable design.

It has a high-gloss finish that will attract anyone and fits almost every bathroom décor. It is highly resistant to scratching as well as chipping.

It is also smooth and resistant to any stains with a stable design. It is very easy to install the seat, replace, and also clean.

It’s perfect for residential and commercial use. Has a rounded front that will fit into a variety of toilet brands with a round-front.


  • Easy to clean
  • Durable
  • Quite comfortable
  • Easy to install and use
  • Compatible with a variety of round toilet bowls
  • A stylish and elegant finish
  • Affordable price


  • Not for the elongated toilet bowls

Mayfair 83SLOWA 000 NextStep Toilet Seat

When you’re talking of quality, it’s never compromised with the Mayfair 83SLOWA 000 NextStep toilet seat. It’s the type of seat you should consider having if you have kids at home.

It features an inbuilt potty seat ideal for children. It binds to the cover perfectly when not used hence reduces the clutter or lifting it manually.

It also features a whisper close hinge that makes it close quietly and slowly only with a single tap. Therefore, trapping of your little one’s fingers is eliminated.

Changing hinges and also cleaning of this seat is very easy and the general maintenance of it is simple. The molded-wood that the seat is made from makes it durable.

It features a high-gloss finish which resists chipping and chopping. It has an STA-TITE that makes very sturdy. It also fits all rounded toilets.


  • Easy to install
  • Remains sturdy for a long time
  • Convenient as result of the potty seat
  • Simple cleaning, replacing, and use
  • Scratch and chipping resistant
  • Comfortable


  • Not perfect for the elongated toilet bowls
  • Stiff to lift

Brondell L60-RW LumaWarm Heated Nightlight Toilet Seat

The Brondell L60-RW LumaWarm heated nightlight toilet seat personifies style and comfort. It features a 4 temperature option as well as a LED nightlight which makes a nature call at the middle of the night never a challenge.

The temperature setting makes it perfect for the coldest nights. It has an enclosed electronics making it installation simple.

It is as well perfect for most elongated toilets. It is easy and quick to use. The most important feature for this LumaWarm toilet seat is the 4 temperature settings. Literally, the winters are the worst times you’ll ever want to visit the toilet as it’s very cold, therefore, this toilet seat makes it very comfortable during this period.


  • Easy installation
  • Four temperature settings
  • LED nightlight
  • SoftClose action
  • Fits all toilet sizes


  • Sometimes the heat is not spread across the seat
  • Period tightening of wingnuts

American Standard 5325.010.020 Champion Slow Close Commode Seat

This toilet seat is literally considered as the best built to last slow close. It features a round-front design made from Duraplast hence durable.

It has a classic finish which makes your bathroom stylish. The slow close of the seat ensures it doesn’t slam shut accidentally after use.

It fits into most elongated round toilets. It features lift-off hinges that make removal easy when cleaning. They also make attaching it easy as well as removal when replacing.

It comes with an instruction manual which gives guidelines for installation, maintaining, and also cleaning.


  • Sturdy and comfortable
  • Easy to clean
  • Affordable price
  • Fits most toilets correctly
  • No chopping and slamming
  • Easy to install
  • Durable


  • It is light

KOHLER K-4636-0 Cachet Quiet-Close Round Toilet Seat

The Kohler K-4636-0 toilet seat is simply one of its kind due to the innovative and stylish technology that it involves. It is basically a fit for elongated toilets and features rubber bumpers that hold it steadily improving safety.

It is very easy to clean and also slamming is minimal, thanks to its integrated unique technology. It has ergonomic contours that offer high comfort and stability.

It is made of polypropylene which is resistant to chipping, fading, and stains. Installation of this seat is easy as it features quick attaching hardware.

It doesn’t shift when using it hence very sturdy.


  • Plastic is easy to clean and heavy-duty
  • Doesn’t slip hence very comfortable
  • Closes smoothly and quietly
  • Easy to install as well as maintain
  • Stable and convenient
  • Durable material construction


  • Slopes inward and not flat
  • Suitable only for toilet bowls that are elongated

Mayfair 48SLOWA 000 Elongated Toilet Seat

The Mayfair 48SLOWA 000 toilet seat is simply amazing. It has a high innovation design. It is a slow close model hence has a reduced slamming and good for use for the kids thanks to the hinges.

It is made from molded wood which makes it highly durable. It is easy to use with an impressive white theme.

It has a high-gloss finish which is easy to clean. Its price is just affordable. Its design fits into most elongated bowls.

Additionally, it has an easy STA-TITE technology for fastening which ensures safety as well as stability.


  • Affordable price and elegant
  • Fun cleaning as well as using
  • Easy replacement and installation
  • Offers a warm and cozy experience
  • It’s durable with a high-gloss finish
  • Whisper Close technology for a slam-free experience


  • Not fit for rounded bowls

Best Toilet Seat Buying Guide

Having the best toilet seat in your bathroom doesn’t only have to be about comfort and preference- it should as well be about design. Toilet seat types are many and having the right pick may be frustrating especially when you’re not so sure what you’re looking for when in the market.

Here are some factors that will help you make the correct choice of a toilet seat to get you smiling:

The Material

You will want a durable as well as comfortable toilet seat hence you should consider the type of material the seat is made up of. Mostly these seats are made of wood or plastic. For plastic types, they are easily cleaned and are less expensive as compared to their counterparts. However, but when heavily used they wear out so easily and are prone to cracks and scratches.

The Bowl Shape

When talking of shapes, we have usually the round, elongated, and contemporary one. Elongated shapes offer some more thigh space but voluminous hence perfect for bathrooms that are larger.

For smaller bathrooms, the round shape is appropriate. However, taller individuals may find it uncomfortable due to limited thigh space. Contemporary seats fall between the two not too round nor too elongated.

The Mount Type

To most individuals, it seems like not an issue but the truth it is as well very important. They are two types that include the conventional bolt-and-nut which is easy to place and remove and also the integral bolt-and-nut that has to be drilled to be fixed meaning in case you want it out, you’ll have to drill it as well.


As always is the case, quality should always match the price. However, it doesn’t mean you go for the most expensive toilet seat offered in the market but rather you should operate within your budget.


The fact is whichever toilet seat you choose, some people have already used it before and knows whether it works best or not. Therefore, take your time to go through several reviews and get to know what other users are saying about that specific toilet seat model.

This will make you have an insight of the cons and pros of every model available hence enabling you to make a very informed choice.

Additional Features

Toilet seat models have extra features which make them more appealing. There are some features that are meant to increase elegance as well as add some comfort and style. Some of them include padded, heated raised toilets.

In those places that are cold, heated seats are appropriate. Padded seas add more comfort though unhygienic sometimes. Some seats are decorated to add some style to them as well as glamour to the bathroom. For the aged or physically challenged, the raised seats are a better option as it’s easy and comfortable to use.

Some toilet seats are automatically designed to open and close.

Our Recommendation

Undeniably, all the above toilet seats will give your bathroom the perfect condition you require but we highly recommend the Bath Royale Premium Round Toilet Seat because of its ease of maintenance, durability, and a comfortable sitting than any other seat. If you are on a budget and want to get the best wood toilet, then consider going for a Kohler K-4648-0 Stone Wood Toilet Seat.


Surely, making an upgrade to your bathroom safety, comfort, and hygiene is vital. The above models will definitely add that experience that dream of and the good news is that they are the best toilet seats currently in the market. Making your choice and increase your time in the bathroom when nature calls.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *